Memories of Childhood: A Reflection on Innocence, Identity, and Resistance, VISTAS,CLASS-12
About the Lesson: "Memories of Childhood" presents two autobiographical episodes from the lives of two women from marginalized communities. Both narratives explore the painful early experiences of racial and caste-based discrimination during their childhood. Through the innocent eyes of young girls, the chapter highlights the harsh realities of social prejudice and cultural oppression. Ultimately, it serves as a powerful testament to resilience, self-respect, and the courage to rebel against injustice.
About the Authors
Zitkala-Sa (Gertrude Simmons Bonnin): Born in 1876, she was a prominent Native American writer, musician, and political activist of the Yankton Dakota Sioux tribe. She dedicated her life to preserving Native American culture and fighting against forced assimilation in boarding schools. Her powerful autobiographical works expose the cultural trauma inflicted upon indigenous children. She later co-founded the National Council of American Indians to advocate for indigenous citizenship and rights.
Bama (Bama Faustina Soosairaj): Born in 1958 in Tamil Nadu, Bama is a celebrated Indian Tamil Dalit feminist, teacher, and novelist. Her acclaimed autobiographical novel, Karukku, vividly chronicles the joys and sorrows experienced by Dalit Christian women. Through her candid and bold writing, she exposes the deep-rooted evils of caste discrimination and untouchability. Today, she remains an influential voice advocating for social equality and empowerment through education.
Part I: The Cutting of My Long Hair (Zitkala-Sa)
1.What was Zitkala-Sa’s real name?
Answer: Gertrude Simmons Bonnin.
2.Where was Zitkala-Sa taken for her education
Answer: She was taken to the Carlisle Indian Industrial School in Pennsylvania.
3.What was the weather like on Zitkala-Sa’s first day at the school?
Answer: It was a bitter-cold day, and the ground was covered with snow.
4.Who warned Zitkala-Sa about the cutting of her long hair?
Answer: Her friend Judewin, who knew a few words of English.
5.According to Zitkala-Sa’s mother, who wore short or shingled hair?
Answer: Unskilled warriors who were captured by the enemy, mourners, and cowards.
6.Where did Zitkala-Sa hide to escape having her hair cut?
Answer: She hid under a bed in a large, dim room upstairs
7.How did Zitkala-Sa react when she was dragged out from under the bed?
Answer: She resisted fiercely by kicking and scratching wildly before being tied to a chair.
8.What did Zitkala-Sa feel like after her long hair was shingled?
Answer: She felt like one of many little animals driven by a herder, having lost her spirit and cultural identity.
Part II: We Too Are Human Beings (Bama)
9.Which class was Bama studying in when she experienced untouchability?
Answer: She was studying in the third class
10.How long did it usually take Bama to walk home from school?
Answer: It normally took her ten minutes, though she often took thirty minutes to an hour watching street attractions.
11.What was the elder of Bama’s street carrying, and how was he holding it?
Answer: He was carrying a small packet of vadai (or green banana bhajji) by its string, without touching the packet itself.
12.To whom did the elder hand over the packet of snacks?
Answer: He bowed low and extended the packet to the village landlord (Naicker)
13.Why did Bama find the elder’s behavior funny at first?
Answer: She thought the sight of a big, strong man carrying a tiny packet by a string was comical and ridiculous.
14.Who explained the truth behind the elder’s behavior to Bama?
Answer: Her elder brother, Annan, explained that they belonged to a "low" caste and upper-caste people believed they would be polluted if touched by them.
15.What advice did Annan give Bama to overcome caste discrimination and earn respect?
Answer: He advised her to study hard, learn all she could, and always stay ahead in her lessons so people would come to her on their own.
Part I: The Cutting of My Long Hair (Zitkala-Sa)
1. Why did Zitkala-Sa feel uncomfortable in the dining room on her first day?
Answer: Zitkala-Sa felt deeply uncomfortable because of the unfamiliar, rigid routine of "eating by formula" dictated by bells, the loud clatter of cutlery, and the constant, staring eyes of the pale-faced staff.
2. Why was Zitkala-Sa terrified of having her hair cut?
Answer: In her Native American culture, short or shingled hair was a mark of disgrace, worn only by mourners, cowards, or unskilled warriors captured by the enemy. She saw cutting her long hair as a loss of her cultural identity and dignity.
3. How did Zitkala-Sa try to avoid getting her hair shingled?
Answer: She crept quietly up the stairs into a large, dim room with three white beds and hid herself underneath the bed farthest from the door.
4. Why did Zitkala-Sa’s friend Judewin advise her to submit to the authorities?
Answer: Judewin knew a few words of English and had overheard the pale-faced woman talking about cutting their long, heavy hair. She advised Zitkala-Sa to submit because she believed the school authorities were too strong for them to resist.
5. What did Zitkala-Sa mean when she said, "Now I was only one of many little animals driven by a herder"?
Answer: After her long hair was forcibly cut, Zitkala-Sa felt completely stripped of her individuality, freedom, and cultural pride, reduced to a helpless creature controlled by oppressive masters.
Part II: We Too Are Human Beings (Bama)
6. Why did Bama take thirty minutes to an hour to reach home from school instead of ten minutes?
Answer: Bama was fascinated by the lively sights and novelties along the street, such as performing monkeys, a snake charmer, a cyclist riding for days, political speeches, and colorful food stalls.
7. Why did the elder of Bama’s street carry the food packet by its string?
Answer: Belonging to a "low" caste, the elder was forbidden from touching the packet directly because the upper-caste landlord (Naicker) believed that contact with him would pollute the food inside.
8. How did Bama’s reaction to the incident with the elder change after speaking to Annan?
Answer: Initially, Bama found the sight of the big man holding a tiny packet by a string hilarious. However, once Annan explained the humiliating reality of untouchability, her amusement turned into deep sadness, anger, and disgust.
9. What was Annan’s advice to Bama regarding how to overcome caste discrimination?
Answer: Annan advised Bama to study hard, learn everything she could, and always stay ahead in her class. He explained that education would strip away indignities and make people come to her of their own accord.
10. What common theme unites the childhood memories of both Zitkala-Sa and Bama?
Answer: Both narratives highlight the pain of social marginalization and discrimination—racial oppression in Zitkala-Sa’s case and caste-based untouchability in Bama’s—while celebrating the spirit of resistance and self-respect.
